John Freeman

Zadie Smith might be best known as the audaciously skilled young author of "White Teeth" and "On Beauty," but she claims her gifts lie elsewhere. "I think I'm a pretty talented writer," she once told the poet Robert Hass. "But I'm a great reader."

Judging by "The Book of Other People," an anthology of stories she edited to benefit 826, Dave Eggers' writing lab for kids, Smith might be on to something.

Who else would put graphic novelist Chris Ware and Irish novelist Colm Toibin between the same pages of a short-story anthology? Smith's instructions to them were simple: "Make somebody up." That permission seems to rub off on the work. "The Book of Other People" is full of writers taking chances.

Some of the characters we meet here talk their way into existence, like Rhoda, the chatterbox grandmother in Jonathan Safran Foer's story. "Have a cookie," her monologue starts off, and doesn't end until she's commented on hair, bathroom habits, the listener's wife and the health benefits of cookies.

Other characters reveal themselves through what they don't say. In Aleksandar Hemon's "The Liar," a prisoner about to be punished during the Roman Empire turns out to have a surprising identity. Zadie Smith writes of a man so obsessed by his own father, he doesn't realize he has begun to bequeath a similar anxiety of regret and resentment to his children.

There are a finite number of ways to tell a tale, many of them descended from "Don Quixote." But a few are new, like graphic novelist Chris Ware's hilarious and astonishing "Jordan Wellington Lint," which cleverly represents a young boy's early stages of development. In one frame, the toddler sits in a sandbox outside a house. Everything in the panel is labeled, just as a young child learns to classify the world.

Not all experiments here pay off, though. David Mitchell's opening story, which jumps from point-of-view to point-of-view, is confusing and jarring. Nick Hornby's "J. Johnson" is somewhat arch and reliant on an inside-publishing joke.

The best risks turn out to be small ones, stories that emerge out of small shifts in a writer's palate. In "Theo," for example, Dave Eggers trades the verve and manic speed of his normal prose for a fabulist tone. He tells a beautiful story. Then Adam Thirwell steps outside of his usual milieu with "Nigora," a tale about a woman falling out of love with her husband in Russia, and emerges with a poignant mood piece.

Finally, some stories are just classically good. A.L. Kennedy, a tremendous writer—if you haven't read her, go buy "Day," her new book—ties her story off so neatly you almost don't feel the knife go in. Miranda July shows how a chance encounter on an airplane opened up a tiny window in the life of a woman.

In a way, characters in stories are just like the people we wind ourselves seated next to at 35,000 feet. They plop down next to us with all their baggage and annoying tics. They might collar us or spend the flight quietly weeping. The difference is, however, in stories we need only close the book to turn them away. Miraculously, in this anthology, we turn toward them and listen.

"The Book of Other People"

Edited By Zadie Smith

Penguin, 287 pages, $15

(2008-02-12)

Also by John Freeman

War Crimes
What is more damaging to a storyteller’s accuracy—time or torture? Here is the heart of Elias Khoury’s mesmerizing new novel, "Yalo," in which a young man is arrested at the end of the Lebanese Civil War and charged with rape, robbery and collaboration. The charges against Yalo are serious in a country seeking to avenge its one-time avengers. If Yalo cannot get his story straight, he faces life in prison or worse
(2008-01-22)

Working Class
Stewart O’Nan has a soft spot for the parts of America that don't make their own postcards: death row, steel towns after the plant has shut down, the corners of suburbia not rich enough to be enviously posh, not close enough to a city to really matter
(2007-12-18)

FICTION REVIEW
Having written one perfect novel, "Disgrace," and several others that can easily be read annually without diminishment of their power, J.M. Coetzee seems to have decided to spend his remaining years poking and prodding the limits of his form. "Elizabeth Costello" came in the shape of essays delivered by an aging writer. "Slow Man" was a perfectly functional story, until Elizabeth Costello elbowed in and called the whole enterprise her own. Now, with "Diary of a Bad Year," Coetzee has fractured a novel into three discrete parts and allows the reader to choose how to read it
(2007-12-11)

Fiction Review
There are short stories that feel like tales and others which feel like fiction. Then there’s the kind of work Nadine Gordimer has been publishing for nearly seventy years—which is best described as a weather system
(2007-12-04)

We Come Bearing Books
(2007-11-19)

FICTION REVIEW
(2007-10-30)

Waking Up
(2007-10-16)

FICTION REVIEW
(2007-10-02)

NONFICTION REVIEW
(2007-09-18)

FICTION REVIEW
(2007-08-28)

FICTION REVIEW
(2007-08-21)

FICTION REVIEW
(2007-08-21)

about Newcitychicago | about Newcity magazine | advertising | privacy policy | FAQ | employment