Tom Lynch

An alternative to the lesser-known underdogs of the alt-rock scene that leans more toward rock than alt, Scotland's overly under-appreciated Idlewild delivers moody melodies against the backdrop of imaginative guitar lines and steady, U2-like bass, while the vocals tread somewhere between a clean-cut hipster chic and an early, accented Michael Stipe. "Warnings/Promises," the band's newest endeavor, doesn't quite hit the heart-mangling heights of Idlewild's earlier releases, but still rivals stiff competitors, especially when the band forges into heavier, thrash-like interludes instead of diving into unnecessary acoustic breakdowns. The record oozes purity throughout as a solid statue of pop rock, not quite radio-friendly, not quite victim of ultra-cool underground burial and not quite what you would want to hear when you're drunk and alone. It's an obnoxious mix of reaction, I know, but keep in mind that if Idlewild were from the United States, I have a sneaking suspicion the band would really fucking suck.

Idlewild plays September 22 at Metro, 3730 North Clark, (773)549-0203. (2005-09-20)

Also by Tom Lynch

In a Great State
Sufjan Stevens tells tales for a new generation, those too young to have been deeply affected by Bob Dylan or Neil Young
(2005-09-13)

Tip of the Week
The Icelandic experiment in dreamlike sound and mood-altering aural drifts and waves returns this week with "Taak...," the band's jump to Geffen Records and most uplifting, dangerous and boundary-shoving effort to date
(2005-09-13)

Starr* Light, Starr* Bright
It's easy to compare bands with similar sounds, to compartmentalize a certain genre of music, match songwriter versus songwriter to see who wields the biggest axe. Stellastarr* still proves to be lovingly incomparable
(2005-09-06)

Invasion of the Parrotheads
Jimmy Buffet and all his entourage play Wrigley Field, the first show at the legendary baseball stadium...ever
(2005-09-06)

Free Space
(2005-08-23)

Dark Shadows
(2005-08-16)

Tip of the Week
(2005-08-09)

Tip of the Week
(2005-08-09)

Tip of the Week
(2005-07-26)

Soundcheck
(2005-07-26)

The Stalker Syndrome
(2005-07-26)

Soundcheck
(2005-07-21)

about Newcitychicago | about Newcity magazine | advertising | privacy policy | FAQ | employment