Service Stations chicago home    
city guide events calendar    
bars & clubs    
movie clock    
restaurants    
specials    
best of chicago    

Editorial art    
film and video    
food and drink    
music and clubs    
stage    
style    
words    
sports    
features    









music

Click for music events

Dark Secrets
The Mountain Goats' John Darnielle gets personal

Tom Lynch

For nearly a decade, John Darnielle only had his guitar.

Then, after teaming with musician/producer John Vanderslice, came the release of 2003's "Tallahassee," and he expanded his Mountain Goats with elaborate instrumentation--drums, lead guitar, piano--elaborate, that is, for a songwriter who built a hardcore underground fan base without ever recording in a typical studio. The first several hundred of his songs were put to tape on a basic boom box--get comfortable, press record and spill your guts--so much so that on the first few Goats' records you can hear the actual tape reeling. After building a reputation of being a star lo-fi artist, and maybe even more so a gifted storyteller than musician, he might have been expecting a backlash from even the noblest of fans for stepping into a new age.

"I was at first, yeah," Darnielle says, "and there were a fair number of old-school fans who sort of expected me to be the last man standing for guy-and-an-acoustic-guitar `lo-fi' stuff, but I figured eight years or so tenure in that station was enough work in one area. You have to expand your vistas to stay hungry." Has that changed his songwriting process? "I still write the way I always did," he says. "Me and a guitar and a notebook and my throat. The difference is that now if I like the song, I send it to Peter [Hughes, Darnielle's partner in crime and on-tour accompanying bassist] and he starts working up his part."

Darnielle bounced around record labels for his entire career, releasing full-length records at a rapid-fire pace--not to mention the countless contributions to compilations--until he found a home in 4AD. And now "The Sunset Tree." Arguably the first "all-personal" record in the John Darnielle collection--most of the other Mountain Goats stories lie on the side of fiction--"The Sunset Tree" recalls Darnielle's troubled childhood, raised with an abusive stepfather and a suffering family, and finishes as one of Darnielle's most complete works. He even inscribes a message in the jacket's modest liner notes: "Made possible by my stepfather, Mike Noonan (1940-2004): may the peace which eluded you in life be yours now." And the dedication: "Dedicated to any young men and women anywhere who live with people who abuse them, with the following good news: you are going to make it out of there alive--you will live to tell your story--never lose hope."

"It was both difficult and deliriously easy," Darnielle says of exposing himself with the dark, intimate subject matter. "[It was] painful at times, but I didn't have to make up stories like I usually do because I already know how all these stories go. So from a craft standpoint, the only challenge was keeping things formal and not venturing into some yawnsome, speak-your-mind stuff. Personally, yes, I did find myself in some dark alleys of the brain, but it felt kind of good, too." That's not to say the new record is all gloom and doom--Darnielle often keeps it musically light, daring to invoke a head-bob here and there, or even a supportive fist shot in the air in unison with a chorus. "I'm a music listener first and an artist second, so I'm always conscious of how something would sound to me... . I try to keep things light and trust the stories to tell themselves without me telegraphing my punches."

How does his surviving family feel about his excursion into his past? "My mom's heard it," he says. "She liked it but it made her cry. Obviously I felt a little conflicted about it, but my first responsibility is to my songs and to the people who might get something out of them, so I didn't really worry about anything else."

Often described as "prolific"--a term that makes Darnielle cringe--the sheer volume of recorded work he releases increases the possibility of misfire, which makes The Mountain Goats that much more impressive given its consistent catalogue. At this point, it would feel strange if Darnielle began releasing records every three or four years, instead of annually. "The difference between me and those other artists is that they are lazy. It isn't asking much of a guy to write, say, one song a month. If you're only doing one a month, then you should be able to do twelve terrific songs per year. If you have any work ethic, it should be more than that, especially if you've been doing it for a while. I've been on this job for a minute now and I don't think it makes me `prolific' to be able to do it quickly without getting all languid-artist-dude about it."

And after all this time and transformation, Darnielle's still the beloved man at the top of the mountain. "I really love the people that come to the shows...There are some people who've been along with me since I was playing to rooms with about ten people in `em, and those people are kind of the core on which the whole big, sticky enterprise got built. And the new people--it's always so exciting to see somebody who I haven't seen before who's so into it now that they've muscled their way down to the front row and they're down there livin' and dyin' with the songs. It's hard for me to think about how much I love my audience. They're my blood."

The Mountain Goats play Logan Square Auditorium, 2539 N. Kedzie, (773)252-6179, on May 13.

(2005-05-10)




Also by Tom Lynch

Tip of the Week
What happens when four hip young transgender writers hit the road together to tell their stories?
(2005-05-03)

Tip of the Week

The Chicago Public Library presents its annual Poetry Fest at the Harold Washington Library Center this weekend for a morning and afternoon of readings, performances, workshops and discussions
(2005-04-26)

Soundcheck
Last year's "Laced with Romance," Chicago-based sixties-infused garage-rock quartet The Ponys' first full-length, took everything we had to give for a local band making its rise to the top of the heap of hipster bands that probably formed after a night of drinking at the Rainbo Club
(2005-04-26)

Tip of the Week
"Goodbye, Goodness" is the rock `n' roll "Great Gatsby."
(2005-04-19)

War of the Worlds
(2005-04-19)

Soundcheck
(2005-04-19)

Author Visit
(2005-04-19)

Tip of the Week
(2005-04-12)

DVD Review
(2005-04-12)

Tip of the Week
(2005-04-05)

Tip of the Week
(2005-04-05)

Stagecraft
(2005-04-05)






Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc.




Copyright Newcity Communications, Inc.

about Newcitychicago | about Newcity magazine | advertising | privacy policy | FAQ | employment